Nicky's Pizzeria

Permanently closed

154 reviews

+1 (803) 748-9661

Photos

Cheese slice and order of pepperoni rolls.

I grudgingly stopped eating because I told my son I'd bring him some. Amazing. Photo does not do it any justice.

2123 Greene St

Columbia, SC 29205

+1 (803) 748-9661

Nicky's Pizzeria is a popular eatery in Columbia, SC, known for serving up delicious pizzas and Italian dishes.

With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Nicky's Pizzeria is a go-to spot for locals and visitors looking for a casual dining experience.

Generated from their business information

Also at this address

Sbmac

Pure Barre

Blue Pizza

23 reviews

Find related places

Places To Eat

Pizza

Reviews

3.5154 reviews

Cristie G.

5/29/2021

This is seriously the best NY pizza I have had in Columbia. Living in NY for years and moving home to SC gave me a serious itch for pizza. Some reviews talk about service. They were very...

Read more on Yelp

Nicole H.

11/19/2018

This was good, decent pizza! I picked it up and took it home, but from what I saw the interior of the restaurant looked like a good place to hang out. The breadsticks /garlic knots were...

Read more on Yelp

Monica G.

9/25/2019

Okay, so I've been coming to Nickys 3 to 4 days a week for lunch for like 2 months now. I can speak better for the staff, and they're all super nice. Missy takes my order almost every day and she...

Read more on Yelp

Sean H.

3/3/2021

Nicky's has some of the most authentic Italian food you will find in Columbia. Low cost, but high quality. Reminds me of comfort food from back home in NJ. Highly recommended the meatball parm or...

Read more on Yelp

Hannah S.

3/29/2018

The greatest slice at 1am. A 4 out of 5 slice at dinner time. They have happy hour, they have pizza, and they have a porch in Columbia where Spring starts in February and Summer ends in November....

Own this business?

See a problem?

Blue Pizza

"Blue Pizza is a family favorite! We love the quality thin crust pizza and innovative toppings. Whether pepperoni, penne vodka, ziti, NJ grandma, or Brussels with bacon, the pies are always..."