The shelves, walls, display cases and especially the staff welcome you at Tally's, which has been selling religious supplies for more than 130 years and has been located at the base of Garden City on Pontiac Avenue for the last five. Walk in for gifts for weddings, baptisms, Mother's Day or Father's Day or first Communion or items for any other occasion. Tally's supplies many churches in Rhode Island through its website and mail-order catalog, so there's no lacking of stock to choose from.