The Fair Shake

18 reviews

+1 (607) 732-4536

Website

Photos

1509 Pennsylvania Ave

Pine City, NY 14871

+1 (607) 732-4536

http://the-fair-shake.poi.place

Fair Shake is a cozy cafe in Pine City, NY that offers a variety of homemade baked goods and specialty coffee drinks.

With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, Fair Shake provides a relaxing environment for customers to enjoy a delicious treat or a hot beverage.

Generated from their business information

Find related places

Food

Places To Eat

Ice Cream

Cafe

Reviews

4.518 reviews

Ruby D.

7/5/2017

Best ice cream around! I have tried the rest and this ice cream shop is the best. The servers are so friendly, the ice cream never disappoints because it is fresh, I can always taste when the ice...

Read more on Yelp

Anna G.

6/28/2021

If you're ever Elmira-adjacent, make sure you give Fair Shake a fair shake. I'll see myself out. In all seriousness, the Fair Shake is a hidden gem. You'd have to know it was there, sitting in...

Read more on Yelp

Ed L.

9/3/2020

I love this place. Hadn't been there in over 20 years and it is still awesome. Only place I can find my favorite ice cream which is vanilla with chunks of peanut butter. Prices are still amazing...

Read more on Yelp

Bubba H.

10/16/2021

Love this place! Great small-town landmark: good ice cream, lots of flavors, hard ice cream and soft ice cream, fun stuff fir kids. We come here whenever we're visiting family in Elmira.

Read more on Yelp

Rich T.

9/12/2020

I'm bias. Grew up on Fair shake. Very sad to learn of the passing of the owner, she was always sweet to the kids, and a joy to speak with in every visit. She always made you feel welcome. Great...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?