Shortstop Deli

161 reviews

+1 (607) 273-1030

Website

Photos

A small convenience store and indoor eating area next to the kitchen

The garlic dough pizza sub with lettuce, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, and garlics inside. Hot sauce on a side.

Deli Sandwich Double ($10.95) - Made to Order

204 W Seneca St

Ithaca, NY 14850

+1 (607) 273-1030

http://www.shortstopdeli.com

The Shortstop Deli was founded in 1978 by Albert and Cindy who set out to build the BEST SANDWICH in Ithaca. Albert and Cindy chose to use only the finest Meats, Cheeses and Vegetables served on offered on bread baked right in the store!

Find related places

Grocery Stores

Convenience Store

Gas Station

Places To Eat

Pizza

Dessert

Reviews

4.0161 reviews

Michael N.

11/11/2024

Highly recommended. I had an issue with the charges and the sub on the same day. They made it right beyond my expectations. Really great service and on top of their game!

Read more on Yelp

Lina L.

7/31/2024

I've been to Shortstop Deli once or twice by now, and it's a handy spot. It's connected to a grocery market, which makes it super efficient to grab a quick bite while shopping for your groceries....

Read more on Yelp

Laur L.

6/13/2023

"Almost twenty dolla for a sub?" I thought. Then I unwrapped the sandwich from the foil and realized I was holding a small child. Even with my appetite, this thing was at least three meals. As...

Read more on Yelp

Adam R.

1/13/2024

It's 5 stars because it's a faithful bearer of Bob's Hot Truck. The PMP, WGC, and the whole collection is still just as good as I remember from 2am on west campus 30 years ago. Other than the...

Read more on Yelp

Billy T.

12/14/2022

Very solid corner store that makes some pretty good sandwiches. I came here with lofty expectations after what I had heard from other people, but I can't say that those expectations were met. I've...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?