Mr. Pot Pie

26 reviews

+1 (716) 805-7924

Website

Photos

You use your phone number to join their rewards. Easy, peasy. And when you use your credit card a"it automatically adds the points.

140 Grey St

East Aurora, NY 14052

+1 (716) 805-7924

https://www.mcduffies.com

Mr. Pot Pie is a cozy eatery in East Aurora, NY that specializes in serving a variety of delicious pot pies.

With a focus on comfort food, Mr. Pot Pie offers a menu featuring both classic and unique pot pie creations to satisfy every palate.

Generated from their business information

Also at this address

Jim's Steakout

Stack

1 reviews

Stack

Find related places

Bakery

Places To Eat

Reviews

4.526 reviews

Paige T.

4/2/2024

So glad I stopped in. I love pies and Mr Pot Pie was delicious! I purchased a berry pie as well as a chicken pot pie. The berry pie had a perfect blend of sweet and tart. The crust was...

Read more on Yelp

Myra C.

4/1/2024

The chilli amazing! The choices from different types of soup, definitely ask if it's dairy-free because there wasn't no signs. The staff were very helpful, we bought fresh sesame bread and a...

Read more on Yelp

Susan Jaworski J.

5/25/2024

Good pot pies with different from the usual varieties. Personal favorite is the chicken curry. Yum!

Read more on Yelp

Gale M.

8/19/2023

We enjoyed our chicken pot pie immensely; big chunks of chicken and plenty of veggies. Excellent, flaky crust that topped it off deliciously. We also picked up their lemon blueberry loaf. I...

Read more on Yelp

Mikkel W.

5/31/2021

It was our first time here; we were staying in East Aurora and driving to our parents' house about 45 minutes away, where there is nothing to eat besides pizza. (It's in the country!) So we picked...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?

PattyCakes 716

"Patricia made a delicious dairy free cake for my son's birthday! She is a super kind-hearted, hardworking person and I highly recommend her for your baking needs."

Eating places

Blue Eyed Baker

"Service - 5 Stars Food - 4 Stars Ambiance - 2 Stars I didn't know that grilled salmon and cured salmon were different things. My mouth feels violated. However, if you like cured salmon, the salad..."

Firefly Bakes

Firefly Bakes is a cozy bakery nestled in the heart of East Aurora, NY, known for its delectable assortment of freshly baked goods. With a focus on quality ingredients and artisanal techniques, Firefly Bakes offers a charming space where customers can enjoy a variety of sweet and savory treats. Generated from their business information

United States›New York›East Aurora›Mr. Pot Pie