Advertisement

Advertisement

HotelsFoodShoppingCoffeeGroceryGas

Island Fish

$$
yelp logo
37 reviews
+1 (631) 698-7700
Website

Advertisement

Advertisement

Photos

Cocktail Trio platter.....shrimp, crab & lobster
Cocktail Trio platter.....shrimp, crab & lobster
Huge menu!
Huge menu!
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Shrimp kebobs
Shrimp kebobs
Fresh clams and oysters on the half shell
Fresh clams and oysters on the half shell
Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich
655 Horseblock Rd
Farmingville, NY 11738
+1 (631) 698-7700
http://www.islandfishli.com

Island Fish was voted the Best Seafood Shop on Long Island by AOL's City's Best in 2008. The owner provides friendly service and picks the fish daily. Island Fish is the local place for fresh seafood, with lobster tails sold at 10 for $20. Lunch and dinner specials are available along with a large catering menu.

Find related places

Food

Food

Seafood

Seafood

Places To Eat

Places To Eat

Reviews

yelp logo
4.037 reviews
Photo of Dawn G.
Dawn G.
8/21/2022

We have ordered takeout here a few times and the food is always good. The broiled seafood platter is a favorite. I ordered mussels to serve at a gathering, they were delicious. Raynah was...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Erica Q.
Erica Q.
8/4/2023

The service at this place is amazing! I loved the mango slushie, I just got some salmon and baked clams! First time here and I loved everything about it. Definitely coming back

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Cristie G.
Cristie G.
2/17/2020

Ok so...it was truly 4.5 stars. I stopped here late on a Sunday and was greeted by the friendliest guy at the counter. I ordered to go and he had me sample so much since it was my first time....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Erick S.
Erick S.
2/14/2021

The best place to get seafood on the island!!! Never steer you wrong... the recommendation are " off da hook" . They will ask what you need the seafood for and then ask you if you would like...

Read more on Yelp
Lisa D.
6/3/2023

It is a very small place with only one table, so I purchased take out. I bought the shrimp scampi that had 9 large shrimps and linguine. It was really flavorful. I was only able to eat 1/2 of it...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
Claim it
See a problem?

You might also like

Setauket Seafood
Eating places, Fish and seafood markets

Setauket Seafood

12
•
$$$
"So happy to have the fish store up and doing well as they transition to new ownership. The Lee's still work there but the mood in the store is happy and just different. I bought Halibut which was..."
Barbara B.
Deans Seafood
Fish and seafood markets, Eating places

Deans Seafood

14
"While really a fish store tucked away in an out of the way back location, the place is a very pleasant surprise. No big sign to direct you, no major sign outside. Nice reasonably priced fresh fish..."
photo of Bruce D.
Bruce D.
Chi Fish Market
Eating places, Fish and seafood markets, Fish markets

Chi Fish Market

20
•
$$
"I have finally found my go to fish market here on island at a fare price! The "Porgies" were a nice size and clean smell which is very important when purchasing fresh fish. The owners were very..."
photo of Daniella L.
Daniella L.
United States›New York›Farmingville›Island Fish

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2024. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement

Advertisement

  • Get directions
  • MapQuest Travel
  • Route Planner
  • Print your map
  • Get help
  • Search the web
  • Send feedback
Learn more about our mobile apps.
  • Android app Google Play
  • Download on the App Store
  • Download on the Amazon Appstore
  • Enterprise solutions
  • Claim your business
  • Developer resources
  • Jobs
  • Advertise with us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Data and licenses
  • About our ads
  • Do not sell