Old Town Mexican Cafe

512 reviews

+1 (305) 296-7500

Website

Photos

609 Duval St

Key West, FL 33040

+1 (305) 296-7500

http://www.oldtownmexicancafe.com

This isn't Tex-Mex, we like to call it Fresh Mex. It's a style of Mexican food that's layered, sophisticated in flavor, and completely original. We use all fresh ingredients, local wherever possible and make everything from scratch. We even roast our own chilies. Old Town Mexican Cafe southwest d...

Also at this address

Shady Nasty's

C M Malta Inc

Kellyenterprises.Net

Moe's Barber & Style Shop

Find related places

Places To Eat

Cafe

Coffee

Bars

Reviews

3.5512 reviews

Jay T.

2/20/2025

As I do not think about Mexican food when visiting Key West, we have always walked past this restaurant. What an error on our part. The food and service was outstanding. Our server Candice was...

Read more on Yelp

Felix P.

12/30/2024

Fantastic service....always! By far the best tequila selection in south Florida (and very well priced on the high end tequilas)! Never had a bad entree here, but if i go out lucky they will make...

Read more on Yelp

Jynae C.

12/29/2024

We decided to venture to this place on Christmas night while we were staying in Key West for the week. Located on the main drag of Duval St, we expected it to be busy with hussle and bussle. We...

Read more on Yelp

Anays S.

12/21/2024

We picked Old Town Mexican Cafe for our spot for lunch out of all the other restaurants/bars in the long and alive Duval Street. They have an outdoor decorated seating area but the bar area is...

Read more on Yelp

Lulu P.

11/16/2024

Cute atmosphere. Good service. Drinks are strong ! Food is ok. Not super authentic if you're of Mexican descent. Plates came out hot and lots of meat. Was not a fan of the rice and beans....

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?